All-Region

NSCAA College Division Men All-North Region 

Logan Rinderknecht - 2016 (Third Team)
Will Pretto - 2016 (Third Team)
Scott Sibik - 2015 (Third Team)
Scott Sibik - 2014 (Second Team)
Ian Christensen - 2013 (Third Team)
Chris Brown - 2012 (Second Team)
Brandon Chmiel - 2012 (Second Team)
Ian Christensen - 2012 (Second Team)
Michael Prudisch - 2012 (Second Team)
B.J. Gottschlich - 2010 (First Team)
B.J. Gottschlich - 2009 (First Team)
B.J. Gottschlich - 2008 (Second Team)
Tyler Holle - 2008 (Third Team)
Ben Terpening - 2008 (Third Team)
Ben Terpening - 2007 (Second Team)
Mike Schweinert - 2001 (Second Team)

United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III Men All-North Region 

Nate Miller - 2019 (Second Team)
Logan Rinderknecht - 2018 (First Team)
Tommy Bitter - 2018 (First Team)
Logan Rinderknecht - 2017 (First Team)
Jon Stopple  - 2017 (Third Team)

United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III Men All-Region IX

Konrad Ziaja - 2023 (Second Team)
Danny Gutzwiller - 2023 (Second Team)
Jack Gentilli - 2022 (Second Team)
Jack Gentilli - 2021 (Third Team)

All Midwest Region 

Brian Hagen - 1998 (First Team)

NSCAA College Division Men Scholar All-North/Central First Team

Will Pretto - 2016
Caleb Sedlacek - 2014
William Pretto - 2014
Anthony Heller - 2011

(Note: The WIAC began sponsoring men’s soccer during the 2009-10 academic year)

NSCAA Division III North Region Coach of the Year

Enzo Fuschino - 2012