All-Time All-Americans

 
NCAA All-Americans
2023-Tyler Hannah (197-Sixth)
2022-Zach Thompson (133-Seventh)
2018-Jon Goetz (174-Runner-Up)
2010-Jesse Milks (157-Fourth)
2009-Jesse Milks (157-Fifth)
2008-Jesse Milks (157-Sixth)
2007-Zach Chambers (141-Fourth), Ryan Higgins (149-Eighth)
2001-Brian Olson (125-Fifth)
1999-Brian Olson (125-Fourth)
1998-Wes Folk, Matt Olson
1995-Phil Wolf
1993-Phil Wolf
1990-Tim McMillen
1989-Eric Chia, Tim McMillen
1988-Scott Arneson, Tim McMillen
1987-Scott Arneson, Steve Raczek
1985-Scott Arneson
1984-Mike Jozwowski, Dave Viaene
1982-Jeff David, Duane Groshek, Jeff Novinska
1981-Lowell Davis, Jeff Eastlick
1980-Don Donar, Jeff Eastlick, Tim Hardyman

NAIA All-Americans
1968-Cullen Carey (123-Champion)